⚡ Electric shock collars & training: why it’s a false good idea

Dog training is far from easy. And without the right tools or guidance, it is easy to feel overwhelmed. How can we help our dog understand that certain behaviors are inappropriate?

For several years now, electric shock collars have been promoted as a way to correct unwanted behaviors. But dogs—sensitive, social, and communicative beings—do not learn through fear or pain. Here is why this type of tool is not a good idea.

⚠️ Pain does not educate

Any learning based on pain fosters fear, which can then turn into aggression. The dog learns to fear a situation rather than understand it. In the long run, this creates unpredictable defensive behaviors.

🐕 A concrete example

A dog that barks at or lunges toward the mail carrier’s vehicle is simply protecting its territory. If an electric shock is delivered, the dog will associate the presence of the mail carrier with pain. It will not have learned to calm down, but to be afraid. And fear often leads to aggressive reactions that can escalate.

🧠 Another approach: trust

Instead of punishing, reassure your dog. Show them that the situation is normal:

• Ask for a sit
• Calmly welcome the person while keeping the dog by your side
• Repeat the exercise several times to build trust

🐾 Positive reinforcement

Reward good behaviors (treats, petting, praise). This patient and kind approach produces lasting results and strengthens the bond between dog and handler.

❤️ In summary

🐶 Get professional support

Seek help from a canine behaviorist and trainer to guide you. Positive education helps build a relationship based on trust, communication, and calm.